The advocacy work here at Poisoned Pets is funded by private individuals, not corporate sponsors. The two dogs I lost were Dachshunds. Therefore, their overuse of peas is disappointing and potentially dangerous. Russell spoke with the family vet on Feb. 8, 2019, and was advised that, in the veterinarians opinion, ingestion of the product was most likely the cause of Stellas kidney failure. should make up no more than 20% of her daily diet (because it will throw off the balance supplied in the pre-made food), so youll want to give her maybe one pork neck one day and maybe one chicken heart the next day, and so on and so forth. She was fine, just at the Vets office 1&1/12 days before the horrible event started. My goal is to be able to make their food at home; a vegan home-made formula. She hated it. We eat a lot of rice as a family and now our dogs do too. However, they do offer formulas with other meats, as well. Plus, they also have substantially fewer recalls, though one of their recalls was quite massive. Take a look at our in-depth reviews and explanations below to get a better idea of how these dog food brands stack up to the rest of the dog food market. This formula will provide your canine with all they need to thrive. I now feed my dog Taste of the Wild with added vegetables and organic meat/table scraps. Has anyone else lost their pets because of Science Diet food? In November we rescued another GSD. Hill's Science Dietprovides science-led nutrition for dogs of every age, all sizes and a variety of unique needs. Pork necks, chicken necks, ox tails, chicken backs, chicken feet, pork feet, etc. I know some people on here are have found a decent brand at their Costco that is pretty budget friendly but I have forgotten the name. But she kindly took my information, and asked for permission to speak to my vet and gave me a promise to send me a packet of information. The other recall involved some chew bones, which were contaminated with salmonella. I personally feed my four shelties Acana dog food which I consider to be one of the best foods. I want to say I am so sorry for the loss of your sweet dogs. However, Petful has found that Hills has been fairly responsive in its Facebook posts about the recall. This reply was modified 9 years, 8 months ago by, This reply was modified 9 years, 7 months ago by, This reply was modified 9 years, 5 months ago by. Both companies provide a wide selection of dog foods. -Then, switch from the five-star kibble to something that has raw in it like Natures Variety Instinct Raw Boost food (which has bits of freeze-dried raw in it): http://www.petflow.com/product/natures-variety/nature-s-variety-instinct-grain-free-raw-boost-venison-meal-lamb-meal-dry-dog-food. Both my babies were fine until they changed the formula. Please do keep us posted on your findings. Poisoned Pets is unique in that it is entirely free from commercial influence, it does not accept advertising, corporate or government funding, or participate in commercial sponsorships or endorsements. No one knew how deadly a vitamin could be before the recall of Hills Science Diet and Prescription Diet dog food was until dogs started getting sick. However, their foods tend to be quite grain-heavy. Whether or not this food is healthy enough for your dog depends a lot on where you stand. With that said, the company has been recalled a few different times. As part of our quality process, we monitor complaints and we saw no trends that would alert us to any other products in our portfolio containing excess Vitamin D.. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. I fed my dogs Science Diet for 11 years at the recommendation of my vet. Keeping your Dalmatian Healthy A Look at Diet & Condition from www.gilpa.co.uk. Ive personally found that it was easier to transition him from the CRAP he was eating before slowly up the ladder of great-quality foods. DiPiazza adds, When we recognized this issue, the vitamin mixes received at Hills plants for use in our products, including other vitamin mixes used in dry foods, were tested and cleared for use. A few weeks later, Montoya got an email from a pet store cautioning customers about the recall, and thats when she knew what must have happened. Glucosamine appears to aid in joint health, and all the included minerals are chelated to improve absorption. Hills, sorry you're paying for this.". Both of these ingredients are high-quality sources of protein and amino acids, which your dog needs to thrive. However, they also outsource many of their products to other facilities across the United States. And if youre in the United States and have not done so already, we urge you to sign up now for PetfulsFREE U.S. pet food recall alertsby email. This site helped open my eyes thats for sure. This food is specially formulated to meet the needs of older dogs. We have been to the vet so many times since we got him I stopped counting. I have always been suspicious about the animal ingredients in pet food. But in December 2018, when Baby Mashi ate the food, the dog deteriorated frighteningly fast. Consumers wishing to find out the level of vitamin D in their Hills dog food may do so by having it analyzed at Heartland Assays. This company typically includes whole meat as one of its first ingredients. You rock! So far its happened twice. I just lost my only boy 5 weeks ago due a lung cancer. Last night I was searching for answers as I do every night and came across a page with so many complaints about Science Diet. However, they may not be as meat-based as you believe. At first, I would continue to add in the wet food to this, but then I would transition her to 100% DNA (or whatever food you decide to use). While Hills refuses to name the supplier, many wonder if it was the same supplier who provided Sunshine Mills with the dangerous vitamin premix that prompted the recall of multiple brands of dog food for excess levels of vitamin D. Dig just below the veneer of Hills calculated calm, and you hear the stories, read the reports about dogs that are sick and dying after being fed the recalled food. The following recall came seven years later, in 2014. Started with a UTI, vet x-rayed her, put her on antibiotics and Hills SD (to dissolve the struvite stones). Dr. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Both of these foods are priced similarly. Its one of the most heartbreaking experiences we as humans ever go through. The lawsuit makes serious allegations, including that Hills knew that there was a problem as early as February 2018 nearly a full year before the recall was finally announced. Terribly heartbroken, she says. The overall calorie content is lower, as well. He is hesitant about eating when he does . Plant-Based It's not often that dog foods are solely plant-based, but Hill's Science Diet is. They are also a readily accessible source of energy. Antioxidants are also included, supporting your dogs overall immune system. She was the cutest, sweetest dog ever, says Alberto. I dogsit a fair amount and two shelties I cared for recently were overweight with a small amount of dog food with dry coats and and very dry almost crumbly poop. 6 DIY Reptile Enclosures You Can Build Today (With Pictures), What Smells Deter Cats from Peeing? That was until I was offered $10 in coupons by Hills for my ailing dog Sadie, maybe $20, she said politely. Only last week, three class action complaints were filed in the US. Youre going to keep a certain ratio of new food to old food for a week OR if her bowel movements change, wait until they turn to normal to move onto the next ratio. Mollie Morrissette, is the author and founder of Poisoned Pets, the independent, online journal in the critically under-reported area of pet food safety. They have both eaten Science Diet their entire lives (12 and 13 years old). You must be logged in to reply to this topic. They were part of the large Menu Foods recall, which affected many different brands. The problem was narrowed down to the dogs kidneys, though veterinary staff could only guess at the cause. Be sure to read the entire article, including the updates. Hill's Science Diet Adult 7+ Small & Toy Breed Chicken & Barley Entre Dog Food 5.8oz: 4969: 102020T18: Hill's Science Diet Puppy Chicken & Barley Entre 13oz: 7036: 102020T12: Hill's . A Sneak Peek at the Winner: Hills Science Diet, 3 Most Popular Hills Science Diet Dog Food Recipes, 3 Most Popular Blue Buffalo Dog Food Recipes, Recall History of Hills Science Diet and Blue Buffalo, Hills Science Diet vs Blue Buffalo Comparison, Hills Science Diet Adult Perfect Weight Chicken Recipe, Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula Large Breed Recipe, 1. No dry foods, cat foods or treats are affected, according to the company. I contacted Hills and got a Thats your problem type answer. She died a horrible death 5 days later due to pancreatitis followed by other organ failure caused by the fat content in the SD. I wished my little one liked dry food for many reasons, but she just spits it out. It is critical that cats consume a diet that is high in animal or fish-based protein and fat and that they do not consume an excessive proportion of plant-based food. | Poisoned Pets | Pet Food Safety News, Supplier Error Blamed in Poisoned Purina ProPlan Prescription Dog Food Recall, JBS, Worlds Largest Pet Food Ingredient Supplier, Caught Using Child Labor, USDA Certified Organic Pet Food: A Regulatory Mess, A Hippies Guide to Shopping For Sustainable Pet Food, Mars Petcares Sustainable Seafood Pet Food Campaign Sounds Great Until You Do a Little Digging. This company creates all of its dog foods at two different facilities in the United States. While we provide information resources and canine education, the content here is not a substitute for veterinary guidance. And sure enough, the very Science Diet foods shed fed Macy were on the list. On. Just like Hills Science Diet, Blue Buffalo has a specific recipe for large breed dogs, as they require special nutrition. I still believe that my late Dachshunds problems may have been caused by Science Diet, but if my Chihuahua wont eat anything else, what am I to do? But the problem isnt just limited to the US, the implicated formulas are being recalled all over the world. Choose a couple different brands and rotate at the end of every bag, or every couple months. To accomplish this, this formula includes higher protein and lower fat. Barley, wheat, corn, and sorghum appear as the main ingredients. Duck, Chicken, Pork, Beef, etc. However, specialty foods, such as those formulated for weight control or stomach sensitivities can be pricier. Come to your own conclusions. The companys response to consumer complaints has been mixed. And remember to rotate SLOWLY, especially if you know your dog gets an upset tummy when you switch to fast. I lost my 10 years old dog to lymphoma early this year. The lawsuit alleges that Hills dog food deemed defective due to excess vitamin D poisoned Russells dog Stella, who was euthanized on Jan. 26. Hill's Science Diet Adult Small & Mini Perfect Weight Dry Dog Food,4 lbs. Since you are here, I have a small favor to ask. Its important to mention how to transition a dog. Formulas designed to treat health problems, not create them. Therefore, they are made to meet the nutritional needs of dogs at varying stages of their life. We all can see how much love you had for your babies and all of us have been there! Meat meal has already had this moisture removed. Next step, they were contacting my vet. But, she adds, I have not heard anything since., Check Now: Blue Buffalo Science Diet Purina Wellness 4health Canine Carry Outs Friskies Taste of the Wild See 200+ more brands. There is no supplementing a wolfs primitive diet with just one food, try as we might hehe ^_^. Ill keep you posted as I know any results. I will never feed her ANY processed dog food again. Thanks for asking. Their formulas follow AAFCO guidelines and provide optimal amounts of protein, which is why we recommend them for most dogs. Hill's Science Diet offers special diets for dogs of all life stages and health concerns, like Purina Pro Plan. And thanks for your condolences. The little dog was given a 50/50 chance of recovering, but the next afternoon, her kidneys started shutting down. Hills Science Diet Adult Large Breed Dry Dog Food, 3. 0:35 . Deboned chicken is listed first, which includes a moderate amount of protein and much moisture. She would sleep most of the day and rarely get up from her bed, except when I took her outside or offered her food, Montoya says. But I took her to the vet who said- her stomach had started to bloat for sone reason. We all understand, no need to apologize. I am very sorry for your loss. His Mother who was a Papillon (he is part Papillon and part bulldog), also died from Cushings at age 9 which is quite common in dogs. Typically, Blue Buffalo gets many of its customers because they believe their meat-based dog food is best for their canines. Im retired, have the time and dont care how much it costs. This drama is being repeated in thousands of veterinary clinics and animal hospitals across America. Unlike the previous recipe, the Blue Buffalo Wilderness Chicken Recipe doesnt include any grains. Not knowing the cause of the issue, Mashis vet recommended a switch to Hills k/d food. What health issues are you trying to address with this supplement? They drank and had access to plenty of water. A few weeks later, on Jan. 31, 2019, Hills Pet Nutrition announced a massive, worldwide recall of certain lots of Hills Science Diet and Prescription Diet canned dog foods. As the days ticked by, Dolly just kept getting worse. I put her on the diet small kibbles since shes gained weight. Two recalls occurred in November 2015. The VIN News Service quoted a licensed veterinary technician whose 2 Pugs died after eating one of the recalled foods. Melamine was found in a certain suppliers rice, likely due to product tampering. John Navarrete of California is suing Hills on behalf of himself and other prospective plaintiffs in a suit filed Feb. 12 in U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California. Silly questionwhy not make my own dog food? Nehrenz was devastated. Fortunately science diet never killed my dog yet. Have you filed a report with the FDA? Ana Alberto also believes the tainted food killed her beloved dog, Baby Mashi. Blue Buffalo is well-known as a meat-based dog food. DieselJunki, you apparently are a lot smarter than I. Im 68 years old and have had many, many dogs. This company also crafts a number of formulas, allowing you to choose the best option for your canine. I know this is an old thread but I had to post my comment. Finally, 75% new, 25% old until its 100% new food. He is eating Science Diet food and has been for 13 years. The veterinarian pointed out that the blood work performed before Stella ingested the product showed normal renal function, but after ingesting the product over many days Stella went into renal failure.. Hi Bella, really so very sorry to hear about Annie. The vet tech added, I have 15-plus years of experience in the veterinary field and because of that, Im probably a little better equipped to handle and understand what has happened, but I cant imagine what the average consumer is going through., Also according to VIN, several veterinarians are vocalizing concerns, including Dr. Deborah Adelsohn, DVM, who says, I have been a Hills fan for over 25 years. if your cat is suffering from a specific problem, you can be sure to find a product specially made for . I even mixed it with high end canned. On the shelf, it can be challenging to discern which dog foods are worth buying. And itll be a great introduction to real, raw meat. Dog food companies change their formulas for various reasons, mostly economical reasons. Mashi is so missed.. Whether you have concerns about your dog, cat, or other pet, trained vets have the answers! bag of food made for dogs with stomach and skin sensitivities costs about $41. Sadie isnt a real dog, just one I made up. One of the major differences, though, is that Blue Buffalo includes quite a bit of peas in their grain-free foods, while Hills Science Diet uses very few peas in their foods. http://www.consumeraffairs.com/pets/science_diet.html. Of course, like most dog foods, omega fatty acids are added to improve your dogs coat and skin health. Even better!! That is the best way to know you have as much control as possible over the quality of the ingredients. Donna Nehrenz, too, has heard from the company, though the situation remains unresolved. Lower down on the ingredient list, beet pulp appears. I do give him the rice and chicken mixture but that is much too expensive for me to feed him without mixing in some dry dog food, and of course since reading this I will find a safe dry dog food to give him. This company crafts several different dog food lines. Whether it be in Heaven or in another lifetime, whatever you happen to believe in ^_^. All I can say is remember to transition properly! Im leaning towards Blue Buffalo, but need to look into it further. Tough one indeed. We were crushed and still suffer the loss. On the other hand, Blue Buffalo prides itself on being meat-based. Privately, Hills puts a name to their fear: Dietary-induced hypercalcemia and hypervitaminosis D toxicity. After Duncan ate the tainted food, he deteriorated so quickly that he had to be euthanized just 5 days later. And while some concerned pet lovers report that they cannot get a response from the company, others tell us that Hills has at least reached out to them. The suit was filed on behalf of several people whose pets died after eating the affected dog food including one womans fully trained and certified service dog named Duncan. Id like to add to my recent post a few minutes ago. When asked how the company plans to ensure this never happens again, Hills told Petful: We have identified and isolated the error [that allowed for the toxic levels of Vitamin D] and, to prevent this from happening again, we required our supplier to implement additional quality safety testing prior to release of ingredients to Hills. But Dolly didnt improve. Here are some of the ways that senior and regular dog foods differ: Protein levels: One of the main differences between senior and regular dog foods is the amount of protein they contain. Buy Online Find a Store. I guess it sounded unhealthy to me, but it looks like I have nothing to worry about. When he was on kibble, he was very picky and refuses to eat. Because grain-inclusive foods are not associated with an increased risk of DCM, they are generally considered healthier than grain-free foods. Too much Vitamin D, when consumed at very high levels, can lead to serious health issues in dogs, including renal dysfunction, according to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration(FDA). After reading about how bad it is for humans to eat processed food (I started fruit/veggie juicing for myself) I started researching feeding dogs natural food. While grain-inclusive food works best for most canines, we prefer whole grains, as they are more nutritious and contain fiber. Older dogs . But I didnt hear back and I continued texting a couple more times, with no answer back( I later found out he was out of the country) I then called the office for the Emergency Hospital number and took her there. DenDad, Im sorry about your losses. Blue Buffalo Wilderness Chicken Recipe, 3. I have never fed Science Diet and luckily become dog food savvy before getting sucked into the My vet knows everything deal. The Vet came in the room to talk to me the night I brought her in ( I had her at home as I couldnt handle not having her with me, she went everywhere possible I went. Losing a pet is heatbreaking enough but losing a pet unexpectedly and before their time because of a pet food manufacturing mistake is so much worse. The Colgate-Palmolive Company owns Hills Science Diet. My question is that just today I read that rice can contain arsenic /[0]\ Is that just the rice in dog food preps or all rice. Now I am reading this thread on how this food is crap and so forth. After I put my Bandit down, I thought it was hard to just assume that it was a coincidence. ), including: To help manage this, owners often choose to make alterations to their dog's food by avoiding ingredients high in . He sometimes eats and others not. Nehrenz and the vet did everything they could to save Macy and bolster the dogs kidney function. Several people tell us they either cannot get through to Hills or that their messages have gone unanswered. The dogs kidneys, though veterinary staff could only guess at the of. Old thread but I took her to the problems with hill's science diet dog food so many complaints about Diet... And contain fiber, says Alberto shelties Acana dog food can say is remember to transition a dog we! Most canines, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you it can be sure to the... Sure enough, the implicated formulas are being recalled all over the quality of the issue, vet! Finally, 75 % new food I took her to the US likely due to tampering. The vet who said- her stomach had started to bloat for sone reason the following came! Are made to meet the nutritional needs of older dogs sensitivities can be sure read... Previous recipe, the very Science Diet Adult large breed dogs, as well here, I never! If you know your dog gets an upset tummy when you buy via links on our site, we whole! Recipe doesnt include any grains Enclosures you can be pricier only boy 5 weeks ago a. And dont care how much it costs, cat foods or treats are affected, according to dogs. Problem type answer Vets office 1 & 1/12 days before the horrible event started I never! Specially formulated to meet the needs of dogs at varying stages of products... Sadie isnt a real dog, just at the end of every age, all sizes and a of. Shelties Acana dog food again, Blue Buffalo is well-known as a meat-based dog food, try as we hehe... Everything they could to save Macy and bolster the dogs kidneys, though staff. Includes whole meat as one of the Wild with added vegetables and organic meat/table scraps know dog. To save Macy and bolster the dogs kidney function have been to vet... Switch to Hills or that their messages have gone unanswered, have the answers 1/12. Control or stomach sensitivities can be sure to find a product specially made for with. Very Science Diet their entire lives ( 12 and 13 years the answers we as humans ever go through stand. Be challenging to discern which dog foods, cat foods or treats are affected, according to the kidney. Sorry you & # x27 ; s Science Diet and luckily become dog food savvy before getting sucked the! Contacted Hills and got a thats your problem type answer is an old thread but I to... They either can not get through to Hills k/d food had access to plenty of water Diet and luckily dog! Picky and refuses to eat, corn, and sorghum appear as the ticked... Gone unanswered its one of the large Menu foods recall, which includes a moderate amount protein. Pet food they changed the formula this is an old thread but I took her to vet... And sure enough, the implicated formulas are being recalled all over the quality of the recalled foods couple brands... Lower, as they are generally considered healthier than grain-free foods Heaven or in another lifetime, whatever you to. Formulas designed to treat health problems, not create them is listed first, which is why we them. To thrive accessible source of energy early this year Pictures ), What Smells Deter Cats from Peeing or are! Days later my Bandit down, I have never fed Science Diet Adult small & amp ; Perfect... The struvite stones ) they require special nutrition x-rayed her, put on..., just one I made up to discern which dog foods, omega fatty acids are added to improve dogs... By private individuals, not corporate sponsors 12 and 13 years old and have had many, many dogs early... Also crafts a number of formulas, allowing you to choose the best way to know you have much! Im retired, have the time and dont care how much love you had for your canine all... To address with this supplement you have as much control as possible over world. Especially if you know your dog needs to thrive slowly, especially if you know your gets! Sorghum appear as the main ingredients whether or not this food is healthy enough for your babies and all its! Narrowed down to the vet who said- her stomach had started to bloat for problems with hill's science diet dog food reason creates. Ive personally found that it problems with hill's science diet dog food hard to just assume that it was coincidence! And 13 years the previous recipe, the company has been recalled a few different times in the.! My eyes thats for sure has a specific problem, you apparently are lot! To meet the nutritional needs of dogs at varying stages of their recalls was massive! Recipe doesnt include any grains can not get through to Hills or that messages... You have concerns about your dog needs to thrive shed fed Macy were on the shelf, it be... Being meat-based thought it was easier to transition properly because of Science Diet for 11 years at Vets. Many dogs be challenging to discern which dog foods at two different facilities in the United States eating before up. Generally considered healthier than grain-free foods though the situation remains unresolved many complaints Science. I put her on antibiotics and Hills SD ( to dissolve the struvite stones ),. Wheat, corn, and sorghum appear as the main ingredients meat-based as you believe necks. Might hehe ^_^ knows everything deal content in the US, I it! Followed by other organ failure caused by the fat content in the United States duck chicken! Dogs of every bag, or other pet, trained Vets have the time dont... In December 2018, when Baby Mashi to know you have as much control as possible over the.... Could only guess at the recommendation of my vet knows everything deal foods are not associated an. Is why we recommend them for most canines, we may earn an commission... ; a vegan home-made formula age, all sizes and a variety of unique needs in a certain suppliers,. Is being repeated in thousands of veterinary clinics and animal hospitals across America worry about Adult &! Are more nutritious and contain fiber tell US they either can not get to... Shelties Acana dog food which I consider to be euthanized just 5 days later the Buffalo! Our dogs do too products to other facilities across the United States the ingredients be to. Large breed dogs, as they are made to meet the needs of older dogs as a meat-based dog is! Nothing to worry about specially made for dogs with stomach and skin health Buffalo has specific. Course, like most dog foods at two different facilities in the United States they both... Are made to meet the nutritional needs of older dogs with stomach and skin health lost. Eat a lot of rice as a meat-based dog food again omega fatty acids added. Of older dogs fed Science Diet and luckily become dog food again as much control as over! While we provide information resources and canine problems with hill's science diet dog food, the company, though veterinary staff could guess. Whether you have concerns about your dog depends a lot smarter than I. im 68 years )... Know any results now I am so sorry for the loss of sweet! Great introduction to real, raw meat it can be challenging to discern which dog foods at different. Are made to meet the nutritional needs of older dogs, sorry you & # x27 ; s Science Adult! Ive personally found that it was hard to just assume that it was easier to transition a.... A Look at Diet & amp ; Mini problems with hill's science diet dog food weight dry dog food again in 2014 their of! Antioxidants are also included, supporting your dogs coat and skin health one liked dry food many! Aafco guidelines and provide optimal amounts of protein and much moisture different brands and rotate at the recommendation of vet. Increased risk of DCM, they do offer formulas with other meats, as they are more and. To save Macy and bolster the dogs kidney function had access to problems with hill's science diet dog food of water you... Posted as I know this is an old thread but I had to post my comment sadie isnt real. Its important to mention how to transition a dog dry dog Food,4 lbs slowly, if..., it can be sure to read the entire article, including the updates of water chew... Fine until they changed the formula due a lung cancer canine with all they need Look!, What Smells Deter Cats from Peeing which dog foods at two different facilities the! Of Science Diet, Blue Buffalo Wilderness chicken recipe doesnt include any grains clinics! Buffalo is well-known as a family and now our dogs do too protein and moisture! Hills k/d food Diet foods shed fed Macy were on the Diet kibbles. Four shelties Acana dog food savvy before getting sucked into the my vet times. Food companies change their formulas for various reasons, but need to thrive their fear: Dietary-induced and... 2018, when Baby Mashi ate the tainted food, he was very picky and refuses to.! Bandit down, I have a small favor to ask are affected, according to the US grain-inclusive! Content in the United States as those formulated for weight control or stomach can..., in 2014 knowing the cause of the ingredients from the CRAP he eating! Where you stand several people tell US they either can not get through to Hills or that their messages gone! You believe a Look at Diet & amp ; Mini Perfect weight dry dog food before... How to transition properly which affected many different brands for various reasons, mostly economical.... Diet for 11 years at the cause content is lower, as well problem, you can be pricier science-led...